
SKIN and Bones, trumpeted here as the
Foo's first live album, is a curious one
indeed. The album largely features scaled-down, stripped versions of some of the
best of their back catalogue, but is a hit-and-miss affair that plays it too safe.
The album gives the immediate impression that it's being delivered on an inti-
mate scale. There's nothing wrong with
that, except for the fact that many of the
Foo's quieter tunes have an anthemic
quality better suited to the hushed appreciation of an entire arena rather than the
recesses of an introspective mind.
This makes slow burners like Walking
After You and Big Me suffer from awkward
pacing, and Dave Grohl's decision to snarl
his way through Best of You is an opportunity lost given that the song's lyrics would
be well suited to a more adventurous,
toned-down approach.
There are a few gems on offer, most
notably the title track and faithful renditions of My Hero, Times Like These and
Everlong. Still, with two of those four cuts
having already been released in an
acoustic format, Skin and Bones disappointingly breaks no new ground.
Unplugged in New York this most certainly isn't.
|